Henry David Thoreau and Margaret Fuller

This blog is written as a task assigned by Prakruti Bhatt.

1). Discuss the following basic elements of Transcendentalism in the context of Henry David Thoreau's works: 1) Self-Reliance 2) Free Thinking/Individualism 3) Nonconformity/Civil Disobedience 4) Spirituality 5) Importance of Nature 6) Confidence.

Henry David Thoreau was a key figure in the Transcendentalist movement, and his works, particularly Walden and Civil Disobedience, exemplify its core principles. Below is a discussion of the six basic elements of Transcendentalism in the context of Thoreau’s writings:

1) Self-Reliance:

Thoreau strongly believed in personal independence and self-sufficiency. Walden (1854) is essentially an experiment in self-reliance, as he moved to a small cabin near Walden Pond to live simply, grow his own food, and rely on minimal external support. He sought to prove that one could live a fulfilling life by depending on oneself rather than on material wealth or societal expectations.

2) Free Thinking/Individualism: 

Thoreau advocated for independent thought and the rejection of conventional wisdom. In Civil Disobedience (1849), he argues that individuals should not blindly follow government laws if they conflict with their personal conscience. He also criticizes institutions like the church and government, urging people to trust their own reasoning rather than accepting authority unquestioningly.

3) Nonconformity/Civil Disobedience:

Thoreau was a staunch nonconformist who challenged societal norms and government injustices. His refusal to pay the poll tax, which led to his brief imprisonment, was a direct protest against slavery and the Mexican-American War. In Civil Disobedience, he emphasizes that individuals must resist unjust laws, an idea that later influenced figures like Mahatma Gandhi and Martin Luther King Jr.

4) Spirituality:

Thoreau’s spirituality was deeply connected to nature rather than organized religion. In Walden, he describes his time in the woods as a spiritual journey, seeking personal enlightenment through simplicity and solitude. He believed that by living close to nature, one could connect with a higher truth beyond the material world.

5) Importance of Nature:

Nature was central to Thoreau’s philosophy. He saw it as a source of inspiration, wisdom, and self-discovery. Walden is filled with detailed observations of the natural world, illustrating how nature teaches essential life lessons. He also believed that living harmoniously with nature allowed people to better understand themselves and their place in the universe.

6) Confidence:

Thoreau emphasized the importance of believing in oneself and one's convictions. He encourages people to follow their own paths without fear of judgment. In Walden, he writes, "If a man does not keep pace with his companions, perhaps it is because he hears a different drummer." This metaphor highlights his belief that individuals should confidently follow their own unique callings, regardless of societal expectations.

Thoreau’s works remain a powerful testament to Transcendentalist ideals, inspiring generations to embrace self-reliance, individuality, and a deep connection to nature.

2). Share your thoughts about Thoreau's statement: "that government is best which governs least".

Thoreau's statement—"That government is best which governs least"—reflects his belief in minimal government interference in individuals' lives. It aligns with his broader Transcendentalist ideals of self-reliance, personal conscience, and civil disobedience. He saw government as a potential hindrance to morality and individual freedom, particularly when it enforced unjust laws, such as those supporting slavery and war.

However, his stance isn’t necessarily anti-government but rather pro-individual responsibility. He believed that if people were guided by their conscience and moral principles, there would be less need for government control. In Civil Disobedience, he extends this idea, arguing that when a government becomes corrupt or unjust, individuals have a duty to resist rather than passively comply.

In modern contexts, his statement continues to fuel debates about the role of government. Some interpret it as an argument for libertarianism, advocating limited government involvement in economic and social affairs. Others see it as a call for ethical governance, where the government should exist but act justly and only intervene when necessary.

Ultimately, Thoreau challenges us to question authority and take responsibility for our own moral choices, rather than relying on government to dictate right and wrong.

3). Discuss any two of the major themes of Margaret Fuller's philosophy. 

Margaret Fuller was a leading Transcendentalist thinker, writer, and advocate for women’s rights. Two major themes in her philosophy are:

1) Gender Equality and Women's Empowerment:

Fuller was one of the earliest voices advocating for women's intellectual and social equality. In her groundbreaking work Woman in the Nineteenth Century (1845), she argues that women should be seen as individuals with the same rights and opportunities as men, rather than being confined to traditional domestic roles. She believed that personal growth and self-reliance were just as important for women as for men, and she encouraged women to pursue education, careers, and political participation. Her ideas strongly influenced later feminist movements.

2) Self-Cultivation and Intellectual Growth:

Like other Transcendentalists, Fuller emphasized the importance of personal development and self-culture. She believed that every individual, regardless of gender, should strive for intellectual and spiritual growth. She advocated for lifelong learning and self-improvement, arguing that true freedom comes from expanding one’s mind and realizing one's potential. Her conversations and writings encouraged both men and women to challenge societal norms and seek deeper self-awareness.

Fuller’s philosophy remains relevant today, as it champions both gender equality and the pursuit of personal and intellectual fulfillment.

4). Compare Transcendentalist ideas with that of Puritanism. Which philosophical ideology can you consider relevant for our times?

Transcendentalism and Puritanism represent two distinct philosophical and religious traditions in American thought. While both influenced the development of American identity, they diverge significantly in their views on human nature, the divine, and individual purpose.

Comparison of Transcendentalism and Puritanism

Aspect	Transcendentalism	Puritanism
View of God	God is present in nature and within the individual (pantheistic tendencies).	A sovereign, all-powerful God governs the universe and determines human destiny.
Human Nature	Humans are inherently good and capable of self-improvement.	Humans are born sinful and require divine grace for salvation.
Individualism	Emphasizes self-reliance, personal intuition, and inner spiritual experience.	Emphasizes obedience to God, community, and predestined roles.
Society and Authority	Critical of institutions, including organized religion; values personal conscience.	Strict adherence to religious and societal rules is necessary for moral order.
View of Nature	Nature is a source of divine inspiration and spiritual truth.	Nature is God’s creation but secondary to religious doctrine.
Role of Literature	Valued as a medium for exploring philosophical and moral ideas (e.g., Emerson, Thoreau).	Used primarily for moral and religious instruction (e.g., sermons, religious tracts).

Which is More Relevant Today?

Transcendentalism appears to be more relevant in today’s world due to its emphasis on individualism, self-discovery, and a connection with nature. In an era of rapid technological advancement, consumerism, and social pressures, Transcendentalist ideals encourage people to seek meaning beyond material success and cultivate a deeper relationship with themselves and the natural world.

However, some aspects of Puritanism, such as its strong work ethic and sense of community responsibility, still resonate in modern society, particularly in professional and social structures.

Ultimately, Transcendentalist philosophy aligns more closely with contemporary values of personal freedom, environmental consciousness, and self-expression, making it the more relevant ideology for our times.

Additional Resource:

Works Cited:

• Birkle, Carmen. “Travelogues of Independence: Margaret Fuller and Henry David Thoreau.” Amerikastudien / American Studies, vol. 48, no. 4, 2003, pp. 497–512. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/41157890. Accessed 28 Mar. 2025.

• Robinson, David M. “Margaret Fuller and the Transcendental Ethos: Woman in the Nineteenth Century.” PMLA, vol. 97, no. 1, 1982, pp. 83–98. JSTOR, https://doi.org/10.2307/462242. Accessed 28 Mar. 2025.

• The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. "Henry David Thoreau". Encyclopedia Britannica, 18 Mar. 2025, https://www.britannica.com/biography/Henry-David-Thoreau. Accessed 28 March 2025.

• The Editors of Encyclopaedia Britannica. “Henry David Thoreau | Books, Quotes, Beliefs, Cause of Death, and Works.” Encyclopedia Britannica, 18 Mar. 2025, www.britannica.com/biography/Henry-David-Thoreau/Legacy.

• CEC. “‘Women in the Nineteenth Century’ by Margaret Fuller.” YouTube, 1 Nov. 2021, www.youtube.com/watch?v=LtxbV94hj0s.

Thank You!!!